Discovering soggy drywall after a leak or flood can leave homeowners unsure about what to do next. Should you wait and let it dry out? Will it bounce back, or is this the start of bigger issues behind the wall? Acting quickly after any kind of water damage on drywall is crucial, and knowing whether to replace drywall is more than just a cosmetic decision. It can protect your health, your home’s structure, and your wallet.

As a company that specializes in moisture control and repairs for water damage, we’ve seen how a seemingly minor leak can spiral into hidden mould growth, decaying studs, and thousands in structural damage. In this guide, we’ll break down exactly when drywall needs to go, how to tell if yours is salvageable, and the risks of making the wrong call.

What Happens to Drywall When It Has Water Damage?

Drywall isn’t built to handle moisture. It’s essentially compressed gypsum wrapped in paper. Once exposed to water, especially for more than a few hours, the material starts to soften and lose integrity. The paper facing acts like a sponge and pulls water deeper into the board. If the moisture is trapped behind a wall, the drying process becomes even harder to control, and that’s when mould, mildew, and hidden decay can start spreading behind the surface.

Moisture doesn’t just affect the drywall itself either. It seeps into wall studs, insulation, and floors. In many homes throughout Toronto, Mississauga, Vaughan, and surrounding areas, drywall sits directly above basements or cold exterior walls, where high humidity and poor ventilation compound the issue. That means even a small leak can cause damage that goes far beyond what you see on the surface.

Can You Save Drywall After It Gets Wet?

Homeowners often ask if they really need to tear out drywall after a leak. The short answer: it depends on how long it’s been wet, how saturated it got, and what’s behind it.

You might be able to dry out drywall if:

The leak was caught within the first 24 hours
Only a small portion of the wall got damp
The source of water was clean (not sewage or storm runoff)
There’s no insulation or vapour barrier behind it, which can trap moisture

In these cases, industrial-grade fans and dehumidifiers may do the trick, but only if the internal moisture levels are monitored with a proper moisture meter. It’s not enough to just wait and hope for the best. Moisture can hide deep in wall cavities, especially in finished basements, and can continue to cause damage even when the surface looks dry.

Signs That Drywall Needs to Be Replaced

In our experience, most situations involving significant water intrusion require replacement. Here’s when you should tear out and replace drywall:

The drywall was wet for more than 48 hours. That’s the window where mould growth typically begins.
There’s visible mould on the surface, even in small spots. Cleaning won’t stop what’s already inside the board.
The drywall is bulging, warping, or crumbling. These are signs that it has permanently lost its structure.
You smell musty or damp odours. That’s often mould or mildew growing behind the wall.
The water came from contaminated sources such as sewage backups, which can leave harmful bacteria behind.
Insulation behind the wall is wet. It will hold moisture, prevent drying, and encourage mould.

Trying to save drywall under these conditions is a gamble that rarely pays off. What seems like a “cheap fix” today can lead to an expensive wall tear-out, full mould remediation services, or even structural rot in the future.

The Hidden Risks of Skipping Drywall Replacement

We’ve worked with homeowners who chose to dry and paint over wet drywall after a flood, only to call us back months later with worsening problems, strong odours, peeling walls, or mould growth creeping into other rooms. Here’s what’s at stake if drywall isn’t properly addressed:

Mould thrives in porous materials like drywall and spreads through wall cavities, especially where airflow is restricted.
Poor air quality becomes a serious issue in affected homes, particularly for families with allergies or asthma.
Structural damage can occur to wood framing, subfloors, and even nearby ceilings if the issue isn’t contained.
Insurance claims may be denied if proper steps weren’t taken to repair water damage professionally.

The longer wet drywall stays in place, the more costly the repair becomes. Even if the leak seems minor, the drywall could be hiding larger problems beneath the surface.

Flood Cuts: A Smarter Way to Remove Wet Wall Sections

In many homes, full drywall replacement isn’t necessary if the damage is isolated. Instead, we use a method known as a flood cut, removing drywall 12 to 24 inches above the highest point of water intrusion. This allows us to:

Remove only the affected portion of the wall
Inspect and dry the interior of the wall cavity
Prevent hidden moisture from festering
Replace the wall without affecting the entire room

Flood cuts are especially useful in basement water damage repair projects, where leaks often affect just one side of the wall or where a sump pump failure caused localized pooling.

How to Dry Wet Drywall (If It’s Salvageable)

If you’ve caught the leak early and are considering saving the drywall, act fast. Here’s what needs to happen:

Stop the source of water immediately, whether it’s a pipe, roof leak, or exterior drainage issue.
Remove baseboards and any coverings near the area to allow airflow.
Use industrial fans and a dehumidifier for 3–5 days, minimum.
Measure moisture content with a meter designed for building materials, do not rely on touch or appearance.
Check for trapped moisture behind insulation or within framing studs.
Disinfect the area to prevent bacteria and mould spores from settling in.

This process is very difficult to do properly without professional equipment. That’s why most situations still require removal, especially in humid spaces like basements.

The Role of Moisture Inspections in Preventing Recurring Damage

One of the most overlooked steps after water damage is a thorough moisture inspection. Too often, homeowners clean what they can see, assuming the problem is fixed. But moisture that remains hidden behind walls or under flooring will return, whether as mould, musty air, or another leak.

We always recommend a full inspection using non-invasive moisture sensors after any water-related issue. It’s the only way to know with confidence that the affected materials are dry and safe.

Want to understand more about the risks of missed moisture? Our article signs of water damage in your basement goes deeper into the subtle signs and how they affect long-term home health.

Immediate Steps After Discovering Drywall Water Damage

	Stage	Typical Duration	Notes
1	Initial Assessment	Same Day	Inspect damage, find water source, and begin documentation
2	Drying Process	3 to 7 Days	Depends on the volume of water and the area affected
3	Demolition (If Required)	1 to 2 Days	Removing damaged drywall, insulation, and flooring, if needed
4	Mould Remediation (If Present)	2 to 5 Days	Professional containment and spore elimination
5	Rebuild and Finishing	3 to 7 Days	New drywall installation, mudding, sanding, and painting

*These timelines vary depending on how quickly the issue was caught and the extent of water saturation. The key takeaway: acting fast saves time and money.

When to Call in a Professional Team For Replacing Drywall

Homeowners can often handle small spills or condensation issues. But when drywall is affected by burst pipes, heavy rain, basement flooding, or long-term leaks, water damage repair is best left to professionals. That’s where we come in.

At DGI Waterproofing, we don’t just stop at drying, we look at the entire system. From fixing the source of water intrusion to replacing damaged drywall, sealing basement walls, or improving drainage, we restore homes to a safer, drier, healthier state.

We proudly serve the Greater Toronto Area, including Mississauga, Vaughan, Richmond Hill, Markham, and surrounding regions. Our team has helped thousands of homeowners recover from wet basement nightmares, and we’re here to help you make smart, lasting decisions.

When Replacing Drywall Is the Right Move After Water Damage

If you’re staring at soggy drywall after a leak or flood, don’t wait and hope it dries on its own. The risks of mould, weakened walls, and air quality issues are far too high, and often invisible until it’s too late.

When in doubt, cut it out. Replace what’s damaged, dry what can be saved, and make sure every layer of your home is restored properly. It’s the only way to protect your investment and your family’s health.

Guides

Do You Have To Replace Drywall After Water Damage?